Re: Re:(erielack) More HO scale Buffalo Creek cars from Kadee...

["Brian J Carlson" <brian_@_net.bluemoon.net>]

Are both accurate, YES, Both are excellent models.  I have both the Buffalo
Creek and Erie PS-1 with the 7' door for flour service and a bunch of
branchline kits for the Buffalo Creek AAR Car. As you know the Creek was
owned 50/50 by the Erie and LV. Neither are shake-the-box kits, although the
kadee car is prebuilt.

Brian
- ----- Original Message -----
From: "James Harr" <bnchmark_@_eclipse.net>
To: "ErieLack Digest" <erielack-digest_@_lists.railfan.net>; "Tupaczewski,
Paul R (Paul)" <paultup_@_lucent.com>
Sent: Saturday, May 18, 2002 11:33 AM
Subject: Re:(erielack) More HO scale Buffalo Creek cars from Kadee...


> Paul and list;
>
> Apologies if this has been asked already; but, how do the Kadee version
and
> the Branchline trains versions compare? I think the Kadee is a PS-1 and
the
> Branchline is an AAR version; are both accurate, anyone?
>
> While at the hobby shop a week or so back I was leafing through a
paperback
> book, one from a series called Niagara by Rail (I think), anyway there was
a
> great photo of a Buffalo Creek 0-6-0 shifting a string of Erie and DL & W
> boxcars, with a long line of vintage (late 20's) trucks. Very neat scene,
if
> anyone has access to the book(s).
>
> Jim Harr
>
>
>
> EL/DL&W/Erie modelers in HO should note that Kadee has announced another
run
> (different number) of their exquisite 40' Buffalo Creek boxcar. These cars
> were seen all over the EL (and predecessor) system....
>
>

------------------------------